| Platinum | Mama 'N Papa's Pizza Grotto |
| Gold | Two Brothers From Italy |
| Silver | Pizza & More |
| Bronze | Ciao Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Best Pizza & Brew Vista |
| Top Pick | Leucadia Pizza Shadowridge |
| Top Pick | Nucci's Italian Cafe & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Uncle Tony's Italian Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Upper Crust Pizza |
| Top Pick | URBN Coal Fired Pizza |
| Pizza On Tap |